Labor Immigration Law

Now that the H-1B quota has been reached (as of December 21, 2009), we are receiving an increasing number of inquiries by both cap-subject employers and prospective employees about the alternatives for work authorization between now and October 1, 2010, when the new fiscal year’s H-1B quota would begin (as a reminder, April 1, 2010 is the earliest a cap-subject H-1B application can be filed).  We describe some of the most common H-1B visa alternatives.  Note that the list is not intended to exhaust all possible visa types and scenarios pursuant to which an employee may be legally employed.  Our goal is to list some of the common options for the benefit of our clients and readers.  We are happy to discuss individual cases as part of our FREE initial consultation.

O-1 or P-1 Extraordinary Ability Visas

O-1 and P-1 visas are generally reserved for individuals who have extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts (including the television and motion picture industry), education, business, or athletics.  By definition, not many individuals qualify for one or both of these visa types, but where possible, an application for O-1 and/or P-1 should be prepared in lieu of H-1B.   In addition to being able to obtain work authorization pursuant to these visa types, an O-1 and/or P-1 approval may establish the basis for the subsequent application for an EB-1 category permanent residency.  Please contact us if you would like our help in evaluating your O-1 and/or P-1 visa case.

L-1 Intracompany Transferree

The L-1 visa type allows multinational companies who have presence abroad to transfer their employees from their overseas offices to their U.S. office (or to establish a new U.S. office).  This visa type is a good option for foreign employers seeking to establish or boost their U.S. presence and for foreign nationals currently employed abroad.   Foreign nationals who are currently in the U.S. generally will not qualify for L-1 visa.  An added benefit to the L-1 visa is that family members are entitled to a work authorization pursuant to L-2 status.

E-1/E-2 Treaty Trader or Investor

The E-1/E-2 visas allow nationals of countries with which the U.S. has trade treaties to invest an amount in the U.S. and receive an E-1 (treaty trader) or E-2 (treaty investor) visa.  See a list of treaty countries.

The E-1 treaty trader visa is suitable if the foreign national has a multinational employer who is willing to transfer them, and the company has significant trade between the foreign country and the U.S.  The employee must also have skills which are essential to the operation of the company trade.   Dependents of E-1 visa holder are eligible for work in the U.S.

The E-2 treaty investor allows foreign nationals to invest (preferably) a substantial amount in the U.S. and obtain an E-2 visa to be able to manage and direct their investment.  The amount required for investment generally varies depending on the industry (the so called, proportionality test) with more capital-intensive industries requiring more significant investment for E-2 application.   Dependents of E-2 visa holders are eligible to apply for work authorization.

H-1B Program Changes by Congress Unlikely

While we do not expect Congress to raise the H-1B cap for FY2010, it is nonetheless possible.  There are a number of proposals currently circulating in Congress, some of which aim to increase the H-1B cap.  However,  the chance of such proposals becoming law outside of a comprehensive immigration reform (which is barely starting to gain ground) is small.

Wait and File on April 1, 2010 for the FY2011 Cap

For some of our clients, waiting until April 1, 2010 to file a new cap-subject H-1B petition may be the best option.  The H-1B visa type, although subject to some requirements, is a fairly common visa type for which many qualified employees are eligible.    As of now, the FY2011 H-1B cap is expected to be the same as it was for the FY2010 fiscal year – 65,000 H-1B visas.  However, as the economy starts to improve and employers increase hiring, we do not expect that next year’s H-1B numbers will remain available for as much as 8 months, as they did in 2009.   Accordingly, we urge employees and employers to prepare and file most or all of their H-1B petitions on or about April 1, 2010, to ensure that their petition has the greatest chance to be included in the quota.

Our firm handles a fair amount of appeals with the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) and we often receive inquiries not only about about the procedural aspects of an AAO appeal but also about the current processing times for AAO cases.

About the AAO

The AAO is an appeals office which handles appeals of certain decisions made by USCIS field offices and regional procssing centers.  The Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requires that all AAO decisions be made available to the public.  As a result, AAO decisions are accessible in reading rooms at USCIS headquarters here in Washington, DC and at field offices.  Also, some (but not all) AAO decisions are available online.

Current AAO Processing Times

USCIS has released the average processing times for cases pending at the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) as of December 2, 2009  Overall, we notice delays across all categories.

Among the most notable AAO processing times:

• H-1B appeal takes 12 months (one month improvement compared to the November 1, 2009);
• I-140 EB1 Extraordinary Ability takes 4 months (one month improvement), Multinational Manager or Executive takes 11 months (increase by one month) while EB1 Outstanding Professor or Researcher category is current (meaning less than 6 months);
• I-140 EB2 (Advanced Degree) takes 26 months (one month improvement) while EB2 (NIW) takes 6 months (or current, meaning less than 6 months); and
• I-140 EB3 Skilled Worker takes 23 months (no change) while EB3 Other Worker takes 23 months on appeal (no change).

Read the full AAO Processing Times report.



The Department of Labor (“DOL”) has provided an update on the current PERM processing dates as of November 31, 2009.  They are as follows:

• Regular processing: February 2009.  DOL is processing PERM applications with priority dates in February 2009.  This suggests that there is certain forward movement for regular PERM processing.  Accordingly, regular PERM processing times should be approximately nine (9) months.
• Audited applications: October 2007.  This is movement forward of two (2) months in comparison to the July 31, 2009, resulting a net additional delay of two (2) months for audited PERM applications.
• Appealed applications: August 2007.  This is movement forward of only one (1) month in comparison to July 31, 2009, resulting a net additional delay of three (3) months for audited PERM applications.

Based on these numbers, we can conclude that while the August-November 2009 period brings certain forward movement for regular PERM applications, it still takes approximately 9 to 10 months for a regular PERM case to be certified.  With respect to audited or appealed cases, the processing times indicate additional delay.